What does it cost to keep the Rohingyas in India?

The little institutional support rendered to the Rohingyas is available only to those with UNHRC cards.

Published: 20th September 2017 11:49 PM  |   Last Updated: 21st September 2017 09:19 AM   |  A+A-

A group of Muslim Rohingyas in Ghumdhum, Cox's Bazar weep as Bangladesh border guards (not pictured) order them to leave their makeshift camp and force them out of the country. | AP

Express News Service

HYDERABAD: The Union government’s affidavit on the Rohingyas’ presence in India made pointed mention of the ‘diversion of national resources’ to harbour some 43000 of them. However, as far as the 3,900 Rohingya refugees living in Hyderabad are concerned, no great support is rendered equivalent to what is given to Sri Lankan Tamil or Tibetan refugees for instance.
The Rohingya Muslims in Hyderabad live in slums in the Old City. They receive no official support for housing, education or rations. In fact, they pay rents ranging from Rs 600 to Rs 1,500 for small houses with shared bathrooms. Most of those who work do so as daily wage labourers.
Any support for the community comes from the local madrasas -- which provide them weekly supplies of groceries -- and the UNHCR, which supports the primary education of Rohingya children and provides them refugee cards which serve as a form of identity.
Neither the state nor the central government provides any financial aid. The community is not eligible for any welfare schemes or benefits that citizens are entitled to. "The Telangana government does not aid the Rohingyas in any way. Their survival is difficult and they live by their own hard work," said Dr Mazher Hussain, director of the Confederation of Voluntary Organisations (COVA), an NGO which works with UNHCR among the Rohingya community in Hyderabad.
"Some good people see our plight and give us supplies like rice, dal, vegetables and soap," said one refugee.
However, the little institutional support rendered to the Rohingyas is available only to those with UNHRC cards. On Wednesday, at the Balapur refugee settlement, two men from a local madrasa were collecting photocopies of the UNHCR card from a refugee before giving him a week’s supply of groceries.
However, getting a UNHCR card is not easy. Refugees applying for a card are subject to multiple rounds of scrutiny, and not all receive a card at the end of it. The authorities check the Country of Origin Information (COI), in this case Myanmar, and follow a lengthy process involving multiple interviews to ascertain past personal records.
"If any of the expatriates seek refugee status, we go through a COI and if the record shows that they have a criminal record, they will be excluded and will not be given refugee status," said sources in UNHCR. It takes a refugee three to six months to get a UNHCR card. The cards, which are valid for four years, need to be renewed at least six months prior to expiry.
"It is not an easy process to apply for a card. We have to go to the COVA office where we have to register. Then the request is sent to multiple processing centres before I get it back. I came here in 2013 and the card’s validity ends in October 2017. I have already applied for revalidation and I will be getting it soon," said a 70-year-old refugee.

Health benefits accessible

The only support -- indirect at best -- that the Rohingya refugees get from the government is in the form of medical treatment at government hospitals. A local government-operated clinic is accessed at a fee of Rs 20 for ailments. For major diseases, government hospitals are the the only recourse. Accessing the health report of an aged Rohingya with TB, New Indian Express found that the patient, being treated for a year now, has been given medicines for his treatment.
One Rohingya woman said: "Many a time when we go to government hospitals, we go with our Indian friends. It helps ease the registration hurdles. Otherwise, the local clinic is our first priority as they know the kind of circumstances we come from."
In October 2016, ICDS services were started for lactating mothers and pregnant women in the Balapur Rohingya community in the form of take-home rations. However, sources said the programme was halted recently.

There is a primary school run by Save the Children for Rohingyas in Balapur in Hyderabad. Save the Children also helps facilitate some students’ further education in state government schools. The other educational option are the madarsas. Those born in India are luckier as they can access documents to help them go to government schools, but even these are few.
What about crime and fake documents?
The government’s charge that some Rohingyas get fake Indian documents does hold some water though. "There have been three arrests till now of persons possessing fake Aadhaar cards. A few criminal cases have also been booked against Rohingyas. We are on constant vigil coordinating with the Intelligence Bureau, the Counter Terrorist department and UNHCR," said V Satyanarayana, deputy commissioner of police.
Mazher Hussain of the Confederation of Voluntary Agencies agrees that there are a few refugees who procure fake identity cards for a better future, but they are counselled against doing so. "Not all do such illegal activity, only a few  do it. We counsel them. We urge the authorities to take action against agents who organize this illegal business," he said.
Conversations with members of the Rohingya community revealed that Indian agents arrange fake documents for about Rs 20,000. Given that the only identity they can possibly attain is a UNHCR card -- which does not ensure them employment or education -- some are pushed to try and get fake documents.
On the question of national security, DCP Satyanarayana said that “three terror modules were detected among the Rohingyas over a period of four years. However, he offered no details.

Stay up to date on all the latest Nation news with The New Indian Express App. Download now
(Get the news that matters from New Indian Express on WhatsApp. Click this link and hit 'Click to Subscribe'. Follow the instructions after that.)


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the newindianexpress.com editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on newindianexpress.com are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of newindianexpress.com or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. newindianexpress.com reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp