Emergency villains who got away

The 42nd anniversary of Indira’s horror approaches. The Shah Commission slammed its protagonists. How did they fare?

Published: 20th June 2017 04:00 AM  |   Last Updated: 20th June 2017 03:11 AM   |  A+A-

June 25 marks yet another anniversary of the internal Emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi in 1975, which turned the world’s largest democracy into a dictatorship. During those 21 months, Gandhi jailed her political opponents and journalists, imposed censorship on the press, ensured that the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution stood suspended and turned India into a police state. Once citizens lost the right to seek relief in courts, politicians, bureaucrats and police officers took law into their hands and indulged in various atrocities. As mass sterilisation was ordered and homes of the poor were demolished to “clean up” cities and to promote Sanjay Gandhi’s ideas, India came face to face with an autocratic regime.

In the absence of democratic vents, many indulged in gross misuse of authority. The Shah Commission of Inquiry which probed the atrocities after the end of the Emergency identified many villains. Among politicians, it identified Bansi Lal, defence minister in the Indira government and V C Shukla, who was the minister for information and broadcasting; among officials and police officers, R K Dhawan, additional private secretary to Indira Gandhi, Delhi’s Lt. Governor Krishan Chand, his Secretary Navin Chawla, DIG of Police P S Bhinder and  Superintendent of Police, CID, Delhi Police K S Bajwa came in for severe criticism at the hands of the commission.

The commission said that Bansi Lal “grossly misused his position as Chief Minister and abused his authority” for purely personal reasons. He had descended to “a petty, vindictive level to satisfy a personal grudge.” He was such a terror that his successor B D Gupta told the commission that “he stood in constant fear of being detained under MISA by Bansi Lal.” It found Shukla guilty of gross misuse of power for his vindictive action against journalists and independent newspapers, playback singer Kishore Kumar and for forcing government employees to work for the Congress Party.

About Bhinder, it said his conduct was “a serious blot on the fair name of any administration.” Bhinder pressured the magistrates to sign and pre-date the firing orders. When he sensed some reluctance, Sanjay Gandhi stepped in and forced them to sign the papers.

R K Dhawan wanted magistrates to sign MISA arrest warrants without looking into the grounds of arrest. A district magistrate said he got the impression that any delay or resistance on his part was “fraught with danger  for me personally.” As regards Chawla, there was evidence to show he threatened to jail IAS officers who did not toe the line.  The Lt. Governor confessed he took ‘instructions’ from his Secretary! Though Chawla had no position in the jail hierarchy,  the Tihar Jail superintendent said Chawla wanted cells with asbestos roofs to ‘bake’ certain people. Further, he said certain troublesome detenus “should be kept with the lunatics.”

Wrapping up its inquiry into the conduct of Bhinder, Bajwa and Chawla, the commission said their conduct was “authoritarian and callous” and they had “rendered themselves unfit to hold any public office” which demands an attitude of fair play and consideration for others. “‘Effective dissent was smothered … Tyrants sprouted at all levels overnight—tyrants whose claim to authority was largely based on their proximity to power.”

This severe indictment notwithstanding, the careers of all these villains blossomed after Indira’s return to power in 1980. Krishan Chand was an exception. Though he did many unconscionable acts during his tenure as Lt.Governor, his conscience pricked him after the commission severely indicted him. On the night of July 9, 1978, he walked out of his South Delhi residence, jumped into an abandoned well and committed suicide. Here is a low-down on what happened to the other key members of that notorious gang:

Bansi Lal: He bounced back after the Emergency, became the minister for railways in the Rajiv Gandhi government and had two stints as CM of Haryana in the 1980s and 1990s. He even has a canal named after him. He died in March 2006.

V C Shukla: His high-handedness during the Emergency had no adverse effect on his career. He once again became a minister in the Rajiv Gandhi government and thereafter was a member of the V P Singh and the Narasimha Rao cabinets. He died in May 2013.

R K Dhawan: He joined Indira once again on her return to power in 1980. Later he became a member of the Rajya Sabha and a minister in the P V Narasimha Rao government.
Navin Chawla: Although devoid of democratic credentials, the Manmohan Singh–Sonia Gandhi combine appointed him as an Election Commissioner in 2005. He went on to become the CEC despite a formal objection by his predecessor who doubted his neutrality.

P S Bhinder: The commission’s indictment appears to have done wonders for this police officer. On Indira’s return to power, he became Delhi’s police commissioner and retired as DGP.
Jayaram Padikkal: DIG (Crime Branch), Kerala police, he was the prime accused in the case of torture and murder of P Rajan, a student, in police custody. He went on to become the DGP. He died in 1997.
What an irony that heroes of the Emergency like Justice H R Khanna who stood up for an individual’s right to life and liberty in the Habeas Corpus case during the Emergency had to pay the price, but the villains prospered. Indira Gandhi superseded him for the office of chief justice of Supreme Court.
Also, as stated earlier, the others climbed the political and administrative ladders without let or hindrance; all wore their misdeeds during the Emergency as a badge of honour. If this is our response to such a horrendous assault on our Constitution and democratic way of life, is our democracy safe? One wonders whether there is any parallel to this in any other country.

A Surya Prakash
Chairman, Prasar Bharati
Email: suryamedia@gmail.com

Stay up to date on all the latest Opinions news with The New Indian Express App. Download now

Comments

Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the newindianexpress.com editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on newindianexpress.com are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of newindianexpress.com or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. newindianexpress.com reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.