Assembly elections 2018: Hinduism triumphs over Hindutva

This column has said more than once that the greatness of India lies in its majority community voting not as Hindus, but as Indians.

Published: 16th December 2018 04:00 AM  |   Last Updated: 16th December 2018 11:03 AM   |  A+A-

Congress Flag

Congress supporters celebrating outside AICC in New Delhi on Tuesday (Photo | EPS/Naveen Kumar)

This column has said more than once that the greatness of India lies in its majority community voting not as Hindus, but as Indians. By far the most dramatic—and comforting—confirmation of this has been provided by the latest election results.

The drama is contained in basic population figures. Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh constitute the heartland of Hindu India. In Rajasthan, 89 per cent of the population is Hindu, in Madhya Pradesh, 90 per cent, and in Chhattisgarh, 93 per cent. By contrast, only 80 per cent of the people are Hindu in Uttar Pradesh, and only 83 per cent in Bihar. Which means that it is the states with the largest number of Hindus that have rejected the BJP. Remember that the BJP had raised its Hindutva pitch as electioneering progressed. The VHP added its bit by holding a massive rally in Delhi demanding a Ram Mandir in Ayodhya right away. Simple, ordinary voters exercised their franchise to show their disapproval of this communal approach to politics. Their action strengthened India as well as Hinduism. Hindutva’s politics of polarisation stood exposed.

The results shocked the party that had come to consider its triple strengths as invincible—the brilliance of the prime minister’s oratory, the win-anyhow philosophy of the party president, and the Machiavellian genius of the establishment’s legal pundit cum finance minister. Each of them is unmatched in his field. But all of them shared a fatal weakness—overconfidence that led them to believe they were always right.

They were often wrong. The prime minister was wrong in constantly denigrating Jawaharlal Nehru. The first prime minister of the country did make mistakes, but all the statue-building and oratory of the BJP cannot dent Nehru’s historical importance as an architect of modern India. Party boss Amit Shah stooped lower still with his contempt for the snakes and mongooses, the dogs and the cats that teamed up against his party. Now that the snakes et al have been approved by the people, will the party chief concede that in the eyes of the citizens of this country, including the majority of Hindus, he is nothing more than an overrated manipulator?

Arun Jaitley is the brainiest of them all and therefore the damage he does goes deepest. He is the only BJP leader to whom Narendra Modi feels obligated. And for good reason. It was Jaitley who first proposed Modi for the chief ministership of Gujarat. It was Jaitley who defended him when Prime Minister Vajpayee himself was inclined to “punish” Modi for the Gujarat riots. It was Jaitley who proposed Modi for prime ministership over the objections of seniors like Advani, Murli Manohar Joshi and Sushma Swaraj. It’s no surprise that Jaitley became the most powerful person in the Modi Government despite the fact that he could not win an election.

Every significant political move in the last four years carries the Jaitley stamp. It was he who thought up the Electoral Bonds, a devious way to channel funds anonymously to political parties. The Election Commission itself objected to it, but Jaitley didn’t care. His drive to bring the Reserve Bank under the government’s control has been relentless. Urjit Patel’s resignation was more shocking than Raghuram Rajan opting not to seek a second term because Patel had initially given the impression that he was pliant and obedient. Evidently even he found the government’s demands unacceptable. These demands boil down to accessing the Reserve Bank’s assets for the government’s politically-motivated spending schemes. No other finance minister had taken liberties with the RBI’s autonomy and assets. What Jaitley proved in the process was that he had no qualms about distorting even the foundational principles of the country’s economic structure for political purposes.

Major policy initiatives of the last four years reflect the same authoritarian approach: Demonetisation that wrecked the lives of citizens in unprecedented ways, the Goods and Services Tax that complicated the system instead of simplifying it, inaction on bad loans by banks that benefited party cronies. Arun Jaitley welcomed occasions to dwell on these issues, more than any other party leader. The frequency of his television interviews is an example. On all those occasions he justified every self-centred anti-people move with an air of grandeur that suggested that people who disagreed with him were mentally retarded.
Those people have now told the BJP that communal passions have no place in politics. Will the BJP pay heed, or will it turn vengeful? Power in Delhi is in its hands for another quarter. Power is a hydra-headed beast and a quarter year is a long time. Momentous days are upon us.

Stay up to date on all the latest T J S George news with The New Indian Express App. Download now
(Get the news that matters from New Indian Express on WhatsApp. Click this link and hit 'Click to Subscribe'. Follow the instructions after that.)


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

  • Sujit Kumar

    George do you have a clue of what you are stereotyping. ?? This is typical of people who have no idea of what hindu or hinduism means. I forgive you for your ignorance but for most hindus our religion or way of life has nothing to do with polity or politics. The same is not true for muslims and christians however . True BJP has done sterling work in MP
    3 months ago reply
  • NVK Somayaji

    hinduism triumphs over hindutva
    4 months ago reply
  • Ranganathan Govindarajan

    It is the article like the one by this author cause more trouble to the secular fabric of India than RSS or BJP. If the Hindus vote to congress then they are secular but what if the minority does not vote for the majority? Is it also secular. One can appreciate if one argues on merits of issues. Taking and dividing them on the religious line which always minorities do looks odd that too partiularly from the esteemed author like George.
    4 months ago reply
  • V.R?Vasudevan

    The views expressed are not totally correct.It reflects certain existing prejudices. The non winning of the 3 states is not a reflection of centre's policy. we must understand the many good aspects of the Govt rather than harp on a few dissenting voices....vasudevan
    4 months ago reply
  • CP Venkatesan

    When you talk with your religious background you consider yourself as minority and secular
    4 months ago reply
  • Hari

    The author is right in expressing his views. What he fails to analyse is the neck 2 neck fight given in Rajasthan & MP. Moreover MP & Chattisgarh were already ruled by BJP for 3 terms & was fraught with anti incumbency. This trend cannot be called that Hinuism triumphed over hindutva
    4 months ago reply
  • Bala

    The title of this article can be true provided the minority community also vote as Indians which is not the case. Further
    4 months ago reply
  • Radhakrishnan

    Do You mean that the greatness of India also lies in the cent percent voting of the so called minorities of India to a "selected" party ? Please
    4 months ago reply
    • Tailwind

      So you want Hindus to behave like minorities?
      4 months ago reply
flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp