Pranab rejects Sangma's plea against him in SC

Published: 20th November 2012 06:46 PM  |   Last Updated: 21st November 2012 03:32 PM   |  A+A-


President Pranab Mukherjee today rejected in the Supreme Court the plea of former Lok Sabha Speaker P A Sangma that he was holding an office of profit on the day of filing nomination for President's election, saying he ceased to be the Leader of the Lower House as a result of his resignation from the Union Cabinet.

"The moment he resigns from the Union Cabinet, he ceases to be the Leader of the Lok Sabha and hence, cannot be said to be holding the office of profit," senior advocate Harish Salve told a five-judge Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice Altamas Kabir.

Salve, appearing for Mukherjee, said either the Prime Minister is the Leader of the Lower House or he can nominate a minister in his place.

Mukherjee ceased to hold the office of Leader of the House as a result of his relinquishing the post from the Cabinet and hence, the allegation that Lok Sabha website showed Mukherjee as the leader even after filing of his nomination for the Presidential poll was of no consequence, Salve said, adding that the plea deserves to be dismissed.

Initiating arguments before the bench, also comprising justices P Sathasivam, S S Nijjar, J Chelameswar and Ranjan Gogoi, senior advocate Ram Jethmalani, counsel for Sangma, objected to the mode of Mukherjee's resignation from the post of Leader of Lok Sabha.

"The letter (for resigning from post of Leader of Lok Sabha) is not addressed to any Constitutional authority but was addressed to the Party President.

"The Speaker of the House, under various rules, has to deal with this issue. Mode of relinquishing the office is much more complex and requires a role of the Speaker," he said.

In his petition, Sangma had said the veteran Congress leader was not eligible for the post as he was holding offices of profit on June 28, the day he filed his nomination for the President's election.

Jethmalani alleged that Mukherjee remained an MP till the time he assumed the office of President as "the official website of Lok Sabha, updated from time to time, showed him as the Leader of the House till July 30."

"You should have pre-requisites of becoming an MP but you should not be an MP at the time of being elected as the President," he said.

Jethmalani also raised doubts over authenticity of Mukherjee's resignation from the post of Chairperson of the Indian Statistical Institute (ISI), saying "all this raises a serious question of facts and law".

He cited provisions of the Civil Procedure Code to drive home the point that a "tentative" response to the allegations should not have been filed.

The veteran lawyer said that no issue can be decided on the basis of an affidavit (of Mukherjee) and "the final hearing has to be on the basis of documents, witnesses, their examination-in-chief and cross examinations."

Later, during the day, Salve rebutted the contentions saying that while dealing with the election of the "highest office of the land", the CPC will have a "very limited" role and the rules framed by the Supreme Court will deal with it.

"If the Supreme Court has framed rules then the CPC is on a different footing ... The CPC is out and it will not apply on the petitions filed regarding the elections of President and the Vice President," he said.

Dealing with the issue of the post of ISI's Chairperson and subsequent resignation, Salve said it was an "honorary" post with no salary, perks and perquisites.

"Where is the profit? Please see the Act/Rules/Bye laws of ISI ... no salary, no perks and it is the matter of law," he said. .

Stay up to date on all the latest Nation news with The New Indian Express App. Download now


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp