England lost in pitch darkness

Debate on nature of wickets in this series continues after India win third Test by 10 wickets in shortest five-day game since World War II

Published: 26th February 2021 10:10 AM  |   Last Updated: 26th February 2021 10:10 AM   |  A+A-

Indian bowler R Ashwin celebrates the dismissal of England's Jack Leach with his team. (Photo | PTI)

Indian bowler R Ashwin celebrates the dismissal of England's Jack Leach with his team. (Photo | PTI)

Express News Service

AHMEDABAD: A flat pitch that finished before tea on the fifth day. That was followed by a slow turner that finished just after lunch on the fourth day. That’s now been followed by a match that’s finished before drinks on the final session of day two. 

For a series built up as a match-up between two evenly-poised teams in contention for a place in the final of the World Test Championship, all the talk so far has centred around the pitches.More so here in Ahmedabad, after it witnessed the shortest ever Test since World War II. The jury is out with regards to the rating of the pitch and much of it now depends on match referee Javagal Srinath. If he rates it poor, the Narendra Modi Stadium could face sanctions.

However, there are things Srinath has to ponder. This might not be a dangerous pitch by any means. There wasn’t any inconsistency in the bounce. The surface wasn’t breaking-up like it did so in Mohali and Nagpur in 2015. If one purely goes by the scoreboard, where India’s first innings total of 145 was the highest, it indeed was not possible to last five days.

Then there is the other thing to take note. Batting from both teams was far from ideal. The most potent ball on a rank turner isn’t the one that turns. It is the one that holds its line and doesn’t turn. It is what caused England batsmen trouble in the first innings and that is what cost them wickets in the second innings too. As far as the hosts go, it was their lack of application and lack of trust in their defence that saw them collapse from 114/3 to 145 all out. That they allowed Joe Root to walk away with a five-wicket haul summed up how equipped the current bunch of Indian batsmen are on turning pitches.

Left-armer Axar Patel celebrates with Virat Kohli during the third Test against
England in Ahmedabad on Thursday | SPORTZPICS

Which is why it is surprising that they opted for such surfaces. The last time they played on a rank-turner was against Australia in Pune in 2017. That came during the fag end of a long international season where they played 17 Tests inside nine months. With tired legs, they preferred a square turner in Pune, which backfired horribly. And now in this series, after coming close to one in the second Test in Chennai, they have played one on a pitch that has reduced the balance between bat and ball. Like in 2017, this too comes at the end of a long season that began with the IPL, followed by a gruelling Australian tour which has seen them miss few of their regulars to injury.

At the same time, it would be totally wrong to ask India to prepare sporting pitches. The essential nature of Tests is hosts using home advantage. However, it is equally wrong if they play on similar pitches where their prized asset, Jasprit Bumrah, doesn’t even get a chance to utilise his skillset in front of his home crowd.

Test match pitches are supposed to bring everyone into play. It is supposed to test cricketers’ mettle. And when it is reduced to a single-facet, the interest dies soon, like it did here in Ahmedabad. Over Wednesday and Thursday, attendance figures were just a shade under one lakh. They turned up to see the likes of Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma, Cheteshwar Pujara battle against James Anderson, Jofra Archer and Ben Stokes. In the end, they had to be contend with Root taking five wickets and bring an early end to their party.


England 1st innings: 112 . India 1st innings: (Overnight 99/3) Rohit lbw Leach 66, Rahane lbw Leach 7, Pant c Foakes b Root 1, Ashwin c Crawley b Root 17, Washington b Root 0, Axar c Sibley b Root 0, Ishant not out 10, Bumrah lbw Root 1. Extras (b2, lb2, w1) 5. Total (all out in 53.2 overs) 145. FoW: 4-114, 5-115, 6-117, 7-125, 8-125, 9-134, 10-145. Bowling: 13-8-20-0, Broad 6-1-16-0, Archer 5-2-24-1, Leach 20-2-54-4, Stokes 3-0-19-0, Root 6.2-3-8-5.

England 2nd innings: Crawley b Axar 0, Sibley c Pant b Axar 7, Bairstow b Axar 0, 
Root lbw Axar 19, Stokes lbw Ashwin 25, Pope b Ashwin 12, Foakes lbw Axar 8, Archer lbw Ashwin 0, Leach c Rahane b Ashwin 9, Broad (not out) 1, Anderson c Pant b Washington 0. 

Total (30.4 overs, all out) 81. FoW: 1-0, 2-0, 3-19, 4-50, 5-56, 6-66, 7-68, 8-80, 9-80. 
Bowling: Axar 15-0-32-5, Ashwin 15-3-48-4, Washington 0.4-0-1-1.
India 2nd innings: Rohit (not out) 25, Gill (not out) 15. Extras (b8, lb1) 9. 
Total (7.4 overs) 49. Bowling: Leach 4-1-15-0, Root 3.4-0-25-0.

What the ICC says
If a match is abandoned and the pitch and/or outfield is ultimately rated as ‘Unfit’ under the ICC Pitch and Outfield Monitoring Process, points for that match shall be distributed on the basis that the visiting team won the match and the hosts lost the match. Any abandoned match will be classified as a drawn match. 

Equation for the World Test Championship final 
If England win 4th Test: Australia vs New Zealand 
If India win or draw 4th Test: India vs New Zealand

140.2 overs
This is the shortest completed Test in terms of balls bowled since 1935 and the seventh shortest of all time. 

Fastest to 400 wickets

Matches : player

  •  72 : M Muralitharan
  •  77 : R Ashwin
  •  80 : R Hadlee/ D Steyn
  •  84 : R Herath
  •  85 : A Kumble

5 It is the fifth time since 2016 that England have been bowled out in a session
1 This is the first time Anderson & Broad, who have played together in 121 Tests, have gone wicketless. 


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp