Modi has dictatorial qualities, please support other leaders: Historian Ramachandra Guha

Historian Ramachandra Guha at the Bangalore Literature Festival said Narendra Modi has dictatorial qualities and urged people to support leaders who did not have such traits.

Published: 28th October 2017 02:02 PM  |   Last Updated: 28th October 2017 02:25 PM   |  A+A-

Ramachandra Guha. | PTI File Photo

By Express News Service

BENGALURU: Historian Ramachandra Guha at the Bangalore Literature Festival said Narendra Modi has dictatorial qualities and urged people to support leaders who did not have such traits.
Guha was speaking on the topic "Jingoism versus Patriotism" at the Bangalore Literature Festival here on Saturday. In a fiery and strongly-worded speech, laced with the occasional witty remark, Guha attacked both the Indian left and the right factions and blamed them for the rise in jingoism in the country. He characteristically did not shy away from taking potshots at national leaders and political parties.

"There is a rule with Literature fests in India - more glamorous the fest, more shady are the corporates funding it, " Guha commented on the literature festivals in the country.
The historian said both patriotism and jingoism were derived from a 19th century European model of nationalism, which proclaimed one religion, language and culture to be superior to others. He termed Pakistan leader Mohammed Ali Jinnah's model of Pakistan as an example.

"USA is allegedly the most patriotic country in the world," he said.
"The greatness of Indian leaders was the fact that they refused to identify Indian nationalism with any religion or language, and even refused to hate the British," he said.
Guha said the Indian model of nationalism was based on a set of values which were enshrined in the constitution.
To make a point on the negatives of "worshipping" a political figure, he quoted from Dr B R Ambedkar's final speech to the Constituent Assembly. "Bhakti in religion is the route to God, bhakti in politics is the route to dictatorship. Mamata Banerjee and Narendra Modi have that (dictatorial qualities), make sure your leader doesn't have them," he said to rousing applause.
He said this model of patriotism was now in tatters and was being replaced by a new model of jingoism. He outlined four features of this jingoism - being an Indian was equated to being a Hindu, Hindi being considered the national language with everyone expected to speak it, considering Pakistan as a common enemy, and branding critics of these ideas as "anti-national."
Referring to RSS founder Golwalkar's writings, he said, "Golwalkar's book identifies the internal threats - Muslims, Christians and Communists. I'm none of these but have still become a threat. This is a paranoid and punitive form of nationalism."

"BJP and RSS claim to be authentic Indians, and I have been called a McAulay-putra by them."

"In a piece I had written in 2009, I had a wishlist - a BJP rid of RSS, a Congress rid of the Gandhi family, a modern Left and a new Party with constitutional patriotism. Almost 10 years later, none have come true, " Guha said.
Addressing the issue of why jingoism was on the ascendency in the country, he gave four reasons for the same. Firstly, the hypocrisy of the Indian left for being anti-patriotic. He claimed the left always loved another country more than India, which ranges from USSR to China, Vietnam, Cuba and then Albania. Lamenting on Hugo Chavez's popularity in Delhi University, he said, "If you think Modi is authoritarian, then Chavez is Modi on steroids, and he's worshipped in JNU."
The other reasons he gave were the corruption and cronyism of the Congress, the fact that jingoism was a global phenomenon and the rise of Islamic fundamentalism in India's neighbouring countries.
On Congress, he said, "It's a tragedy that a great freedom movement has been reduced to one party."

"Mahatma Gandhi himself admitted to a Himalayan blunder. I don't know a single Gandhi who made a blunder."

"My colleague Gopalakrishna Gandhi once said, 'Congress disowned (Vallabhbhai) Patel and BJP misowned Patel, " the veteran historian added.
Guha concluded by saying that those who are constitutional patriots should not take jingoism lying down, and should fight it.

Stay up to date on all the latest Nation news with The New Indian Express App. Download now
(Get the news that matters from New Indian Express on WhatsApp. Click this link and hit 'Click to Subscribe'. Follow the instructions after that.)


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

facebook twitter whatsapp