At this weekend debate club, young B'lureans are hashing out education, feminism, healthcare and more

Started six months ago by a trio of entrepreneurs, The Contrarian Debate Club has become a place for Bengalureans looking for intellectual stimulation to gather and debate topics that split opinions
Glimpse of a debate in progress
Glimpse of a debate in progress
Updated on: 
3 min read

For most people with school debate competitions, model united nations and college elections years behind them, the closest we get to intellectual sparring is probably a snappy reply to a social media comment that irks us. Whether we really think through any idea becomes irrelevant, so long as we win in the likes department.

The Contrarian Debate Club, started earlier this year by three city-based entrepreneurs – Sudarshan Senthilkumar, Srinthan Hampi and Sahib Ahluwalia – has set out to change that, reintroducing debating to Bengalureans in a new format where winning is not the goal, but listening to different sides, having constructive conversations and feeling free to change your mind is.

“In the current climate, we feel people are too quick to jump to conclusions or just attack the opposing viewpoint, they often see it as one versus the other. But once you get them in a room, you’d be surprised to see how many people are listening even if they might disagree. We need more spaces like this,” says Senthilkumar. ‘What’s holding India back from producing world-class universities?’, ‘Should Indians stop celebrating festivals abroad?’ and ‘Change My Mind: Hospitals should not be for-profit’, have been some of the topics debated so far, along with those on choice feminism, CJP’s school visits, and other topics which would inspire strong views. “A lot of the topics start off as ideas from conversations we have among friends or hangouts after debate club meetings. We realise that it’s important to pick a really good topic, so we argue it amongst ourselves for a week or two until we reach a point where the motion is balanced on both sides, and it’s very hard to reach a conclusion,” explains Senthilkumar, adding that while the topics themselves might be neutral, ‘while framing the motion, we might pick one side over another if we feel like the room already leans towards one side, so that they are forced to think on the other.’

Founder Sudarshan Senthilkumar
Founder Sudarshan Senthilkumar

Initially, two primary debaters are picked at random to present both sides of the argument, followed by an open floor where anyone can bring up their points. “Once the case is presented, the job of the audience is to bring up flaws or better ideas than the ones that were presented,” says Senthilkumar, adding, “It’s not like the person who’s presenting versus the audience. It’s the room versus the problem. For example, with how to improve government schools, the presenter lays out ground realities, problems and how they’re thinking about solving it, and the job of the room is to identify better ideas, flaws in their way of thinking and come up with better ideas.”

The rules are simple: stay respectful and if you think an idea is bad, come up with a better one. Unlike typical debates, there is no winner but an app-based survey measures what the room believes before and after the debate, quantifying how ideas and beliefs have shifted through the discussion.

(The next debate is set to take place on November 22, discussing GenZ and AI in Mental Health. For more information, visit @thecontrarian.club on Instagram)