Should you repair or discard your gadgets?

From as late as the 1920s, due to "planned obsolescence", electronic goods are being purposefully manufactured in such a way that they are rendered obsolete after a predetermined period.
Apart from having a monopoly over repairs, big companies also give rise to more e-waste as electronic items become obsolete sooner. (Representational Photo)
Apart from having a monopoly over repairs, big companies also give rise to more e-waste as electronic items become obsolete sooner. (Representational Photo)

HYDERABAD:  We buy smartphones, laptops, fridges, watches, cars. When these break down, we could throw them away, but choose to repair them instead. In the US and Europe, it is illegal for anyone other than their authorised service centres to repair their items. But, in India, we have a range of friendly neighbourhood repair shops and garages that need no authorisation to repair your defunct gadgets.

In early July, POTUS Joe Biden passed an executive order to promote economic competition in the country and curb restrictions that limit consumers’ ability to repair gadgets on their terms. This order was a result of years of fighting by the right to repair movement in the West, which aims to provide buyers the autonomy to repair gadgets on their own terms.

The right to repair movement was a reaction to an age-old strategy employed by manufacturers called ‘planned obsolescence’. From as late as the 1920s, due to planned obsolescence, electronic goods are being purposefully manufactured in such a way that they are rendered obsolete after a predetermined period, so that consumers are forced to either get their machines fixed or discard them and keep buying new ones.

The movement also advocates for companies to supply maintenance manuals and spare parts along with their machines. “India not only has jugaad repair shops but also such policies. We should definitely have the right to repair in our country too. Maintenance manuals, spare parts and diagnostic software should be available by law,” says Parminder Jeet Singh, a Senior Fellow at the IT for Change.

Apart from having a monopoly over repairs, big companies also give rise to more e-waste as electronic items become obsolete sooner. “If part of my laptop’s motherboard cannot be changed, the entire motherboard has to be replaced. Firstly, this is costly and secondly, this adds to more e-waste,” says Praveen Chandrahas from the Forum for IT Employees. As per data released by Apple, mining and manufacturing materials used to make an iPhone ‘represent 83 per cent of its contribution to the heat-trapping emissions in the atmosphere throughout its life cycle’. 

Not all hacks work

Dry rice to treat wet mobiles
Probably the oldest trick in the book is storing your wet mobile phone in a bag or container of uncooked rice so that it extracts the water from the phone. “Though rice is an absorbent, it will not drain out all the water from the phone, maybe just 13 per cent,” says a repairman at a shop in Ameerpet. Rice may absorb some of the water, but it cannot prevent the corrosion of the motherboard. In fact, rice will further damage the phone since its remnants can speed up the corrosion.

Using a blow-dryer
Great for drying your hair but do not use a blow-dryer to dry your wet phone, says another mechanic. The heat from the blow-dryer will damage your phone. However, if you still manage to control the heat, the salts from the water that will remain on your phone will further damage your phone. Additionally, using a blow-dryer will push the moisture inside the parts of the phone that were not wet to begin with.

Toothpaste to fix cracks on screen
Using toothpaste to fix a cracked screen is a common fix that has been floating around the Internet. Apart from making a few small scratches disappear, toothpaste doesn’t really fix a cracked phone screen. The reason why this ‘hack’ was popular is because toothpaste fills in small scratches on the screen.

Related Stories

No stories found.

X
The New Indian Express
www.newindianexpress.com