HC junks case against man for social media post targeting Siddu

The petitioner had merely reposted the said photograph of the breaking news on his X account, which, by itself, does not prima facie attract the provisions of Section 153A of IPC.
HC junks case against man for social media post targeting Siddu
Updated on: 
2 min read

BENGALURU: The Karnataka High Court quashed the proceedings against a man on charges of creating communal hatred by taking a photograph of the then Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and posting the same on his X account with a write-up alleging that the Congress party intended to take away the wealth belonging to Hindus and distribute it only to a particular community.

Justice Rajesh Rai K passed the order while allowing the petition filed by Vinith Narayan Naik from Thane, challenging the case registered with the cybercrime police in the city by J Saravananan from the city under the provisions of the Information Technology Act and IPC.

“Even if the allegations in the complaint and FIR are accepted in their entirety, no offence is made out against the petitioner. Therefore, the continuation of the FIR and further proceedings against the petitioner would amount to abuse of the process of court”, the judge observed.

A case was registered on April 29, 2024, alleging that some unknown persons had been posting on X through an account with the intention of promoting hatred between the Hindu and Muslim communities, disturbing public peace and bringing disrepute to the Congress party.

It was contended on behalf of the petitioner that the only allegation against the petitioner is that he had criticised/commented upon the Congress manifesto by posting a photograph of Siddaramaiah, the then chief minister, along with his byte to the electronic media channel, which allegedly disseminated a breaking news item with a headline stating that he had remarked that the wealth of the nation would be distributed to Muslims, along with his photograph. The petitioner had merely reposted the said photograph of the breaking news on his X account, which, by itself, does not prima facie attract the provisions of Section 153A of IPC.

However, the state public prosecutor contended that the then chief minister had stated that the wealth of the nation would be distributed even to the Muslim community. However, the media channel, while disseminating the said news item as breaking news, had published a headline, along with the photograph of the then chief minister, stating that the chief minister would distribute the wealth of the nation to Muslims, he argued while defending the crime registered against the petitioner.