CM Satheesan’s style sparks dissent in UDF cabinet

Satheesan sought to play down the criticism, arguing that every decision need not be discussed with everyone.
Keralam Chief Minister VD Satheesan
Keralam Chief Minister VD SatheesanExpress Photo
Updated on: 
3 min read

THIRUVANANTHAPURAM: Just six months into office, major differences have cropped up in the UDF government with three ministers — from the Congress and a constituent party — coming out against Chief Minister V D Satheesan’s style of functioning in the cabinet meeting on Wednesday.

Senior ministers Shibu Baby John, A P Anil Kumar and Sunny Joseph questioned the chief minister over lack of consultations on key appointments and government decisions, highly placed sources told TNIE.

At the cabinet meet, the discussion on appointments to Guruvayoor Devaswom Board and PSC soon turned into a sharp exchange, with the ministers airing their dissent. Interventions by senior leaders P K Kunhalikutty and K Muraleedharan failed, while Ramesh Chennithala, who usually backs the CM during controversies, chose to remain silent.

The immediate trigger was Satheesan’s proposal to appoint three members to the devaswom board and five to the PSC, apparently without discussions in the cabinet.

According to sources, there were not many objections to devaswom appointments. However, they pointed out that the CM came to the cabinet meet with already finalised names for the PSC posts. While various factions and leaders had pushed several names, Satheesan allotted one post to the IUML before proposing candidates of his own choice for majority of posts. Shibu objected strongly, seeking greater consultations on the appointments before they were brought before the cabinet, sources said.

Satheesan sought to play down the criticism, arguing that every decision need not be discussed with everyone. This led to further exchanges, with Anil Kumar questioning the CM’s earlier public assertion that he consults the KPCC president, former PCC presidents and working presidents before taking decisions. “Were discussions held with these leaders before taking this decision?” the minister is learnt to have asked.

Sunny, who is also the KPCC president, backed the objection, stating that no such consultations took place between him and the CM.

‘There’ll be no unilateral decision in UDF cabinet’

Sources said Sunny alleged that he was occasionally briefed on certain matters merely to create the impression that consultations had taken place, without any subsequent follow-up or discussion.

Muraleedharan, who maintained that the devaswom board appointments had been made after consulting him, also faced resistance from ministers unwilling to accept the argument. Kunhalikutty, one of the CM’s key supporters in the cabinet, intervened to defend Satheesan, questioning the heated arguments among ministers. However, he failed to persuade the objecting ministers, who countered him along similar lines, reiterating that there had been no meaningful consultation.

Kerala Congress (Jacob) leader and Minister Anoop Jacob made efforts to defuse the tension and pacify some ministers. Curiously, Chennithala, who along with Kunhalikutty had defended the CM in past controversies, including over the PM SHRI project, did not intervene in Wednesday’s arguments at all. Later, the CM and ministers agreed to resolve the appointments of PSC members through consensus.

The differences between the CM and his cabinet colleagues come close on the heels of UDF convener Adoor Prakash alleging lack of consultation and the KPCC president expressing reservations over the power purchase proposal weeks ago.

Briefing the media in New Delhi later, Satheesan admitted that the cabinet meeting did witness extensive arguments and lasted two-and-a-half hours. “There were arguments on many matters. I say it with pride. Unanimous decisions were reached on all matters,” he said.

“This is not Pinarayi Vijayan’s cabinet. This is not a cabinet of ‘yes-men’ who agrees to every decision written on a piece of paper that Pinarayi Vijayan pulls out of his pocket,” he said. “We discussed the Higher Education Bill for an hour. In our cabinet, there will be arguments, different opinions will be voiced, alternative opinions will be expressed, and finally a decision will be made. Even the most junior minister, Janeesh, could express his opinion,” he added.

On Sunny’s statement that he was not consulted on the power purchase proposal, Satheesan said the KPCC president was free to express his views. “There will be no unilateral decision in this UDF cabinet,” he said.