Madras HC allows lorry driver's wife to view CCTV footage in custodial death case

Pursuant to earlier directions issued by the court, the police submitted two copies of the footage sought by the petitioner before the High Court, along with relevant certificates.
Madurai Bench of the Madras HC
Madurai Bench of the Madras HC File Photo | Express
Updated on: 
2 min read

MADURAI: The Madurai Bench of Madras HC has permitted the wife of a lorry driver who allegedly died by suicide at Chekkanurani police station on November 14, to view the CCTV footage recorded at four police stations connected with her husband’s death, at CBCID’s office in Madurai on Monday. Her advocate and two of her family members were allowed to accompany her.

Justice R Vijayakumar granted this permission on condition that all the above persons should leave their electronic devices outside the viewing room and should refrain from recording the clippings.

A technical staff from CBCID should be made available in the hall to assist them, he added. “The permission granted to the petitioner is solely for the purpose of satisfying themselves as to the line and direction of the investigation. What they view may be used only for approaching a statutory forum. No press meet or public debate shall follow the viewing of the CCTV footage,” Justice Vijayakumar said.

He further clarified that the above order is passed only in view of the fact that the case relates to alleged custodial torture or custodial death.
The judge issued the directions on Friday, while disposing of a petition filed by B Sudha, wife of the deceased Balakrishnan, seeking direction to preserve and get a copy of the CCTV footage recorded at four police stations- Chekkanurani, Usilampatti town and taluk, Valandur- where the deceased was said to have gone or had been taken to by the police prior to his death.

Pursuant to earlier directions issued by the court, the police submitted two copies of the footage sought by the petitioner before the high court, along with relevant certificates.

However, the additional public prosecutor representing the CBCID objected to furnishing a copy of the footage to the petitioner, saying the footage is required to be produced only before the jurisdictional magistrate. Handing over the footage to the petitioner while the investigation is pending, particularly in a sensitive case such as this, would clearly impede the investigation, he added. He further feared that the footage may also be tampered with and published on social media and press meets may be conducted, resulting in them being used as a political tool.

Justice Vijayakumar wondered why the deceased, being a complainant, was made to wait throughout the night at Chekkanurani police station.
“A complainant would have no occasion whatsoever to commit suicide inside a police station,” he added.

Though it is alleged that certain complaints were lodged by the employer of the deceased, no FIR has been registered on those complaints, he noted. Since the postmortem report reveals some injuries on the body of the deceased, only the CCTV footage could throw light on the direction of the investigation, he added.