Madras HC allows DMK to sue ministers for Rs 1 crore damages

Justice K Govindarajan Thilakavadi allowed the application filed by the DMK seeking grant of leave to file the defamation suit claiming Rs 1.01 crore in damages.
Madras HC
Madras HC File Photo | IANS
Updated on: 
2 min read

CHENNAI: The Madras High Court on Monday granted leave to the principal opposition party, DMK, to sue TVK leaders and ministers CTR Nirmal Kumar (Law and Electricity) and Aadhav Arjuna (PWD) for making defamatory statements against the Dravidian party regarding the sexual assault case against 'Gem' Granites founder R Veeramani.

Justice K Govindarajan Thilakavadi allowed the application filed by the DMK seeking grant of leave to file the defamation suit claiming Rs 1.01 crore damages and restraining both the ministers from making such defamatory statements that the party had protected the perpetrators. The application was filed by Durai Murugan, general secretary of DMK.

Advocate General Vijay Narayan, senior counsel Satish Parasaran and advocate G Murugendran representing the ministers and the TVK IT Wing, had objected to granting leave since prior notice mandated under section 80 of Civil Procedure Code (CPC) was not served since the defendants are holding public office and said the IT Wing is not a legal entity.

However, senior counsel J Ravindran appearing for Durai Murugan contended the defamation suit is being filed against Nirmal Kumar and Aadhav Arjuna in their individual capacity as leaders of TVK and not as persons holding public office.

And so, notice under section 80 of CPC is not required to be served, he said.

Justice Thilakavadi said, "Whether Section 80 CPC is attracted to the proposed suit, whether any exception under the provision is applicable, whether the respondents are properly described as Public Officers and the consequence, if any, of non-service of notice are matters which can be considered in the suit at the appropriate stage. As discussed above, those questions do not, on the facts pleaded, furnish a ground to reject the present application for leave at the threshold."

On a consideration of the averments in the proposed plaint, this court is satisfied that the applicant has pleaded that a substantial and material part of the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of this court. The fact that some of the defendants are situated outside the jurisdiction does not, by itself, disentitle the applicant from invoking the jurisdiction of this Court where the requirements of Clause 12 of CPC are otherwise satisfied, the judge said in the order.

Stating that the scope of consideration in an application seeking leave under Clause 12 is limited, the judge said at this stage, the court is "not required to conduct a mini trial or conclusively determine" disputed questions concerning the ultimate maintainability of the suit.