Try to build consensus, KRMB tells Andhra and Telangana

Project-wise allocations remained to be determined by the competent Tribunal.
The Board advised them to comply with Principle 7 of the Eleventh Schedule of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014, which requires new projects to undergo prior appraisal and technical clearance by the respective Board before being sanctioned by the Apex Council.
The Board advised them to comply with Principle 7 of the Eleventh Schedule of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014, which requires new projects to undergo prior appraisal and technical clearance by the respective Board before being sanctioned by the Apex Council.File Photo
Updated on: 
2 min read

HYDERABAD: With Andhra Pradesh (AP) and Telangana lodging complaints against each other over 20 unauthorised irrigation projects/structures’, the Krishna River Management Board (KRMB) on Thursday said that all new projects required prior appraisal and technical clearance. It also said that contentious issues would remain inconclusive in the absence of consensus between the two states.

In a letter to the Irrigation secretaries of both states, the KRMB said that project conception or construction based on presumed availability of unallocated or surplus water did not, by itself, confer an assured or legally enforceable entitlement to its utilisation. Project-wise allocations remained to be determined by the competent Tribunal.

Responding to requests from both states to restrain each other from constructing unapproved projects, the Board advised them to comply with Principle 7 of the Eleventh Schedule of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014, which requires new projects to undergo prior appraisal and technical clearance by the respective Board before being sanctioned by the Apex Council.

The Board also pointed out that the Telangana government had challenged the Ministry of Jal Shakti’s Jurisdiction Notification, 2021, before the Supreme Court in WP (C) No. 666/2024, questioning its constitutional validity and seeking its quashing.

The notification underpins the Board’s jurisdiction and functions, including project appraisal under Section 85(8) of the AP Reorganisation Act, 2014.

“Now, seeking the Board’s intervention while assailing the very notification conferring its jurisdiction is inherently contradictory,” the letter said.

“The Board’s decisions are generally taken by consensus under Clause 6(iii) of its meeting procedure. A contested matter, in the absence of consensus, remains inconclusive unless deferment is specially recorded under Clause 6(ii),” it said. 

KRMB to AP, TG: Follow statutory clearance before seeking nod

The KRMB also said that “The Board’s ability to take decisions on such matters is thus constrained by its consensus-based procedure, further compounded by the challenge to its jurisdictional framework before the Supreme Court.”

It also noted that Principle 9 of the Eleventh Schedule to the AP Reorganisation Act provides for consequential action by the Union government in the event of failure to implement a Board decision. Its invocation, therefore, presupposes a decision that is not affected by jurisdictional issues and its subsequent non-implementation by the state concerned.

The KRMB reiterated that both states must follow the statutory sequence of prior appraisal and technical clearance before seeking the Apex Council’s sanction for new projects. It also made it clear that the construction of projects based on presumed availability of unallocated or surplus water did not create an assured or legally enforceable right to use it.