Rahul's Inglorious Past Can be Forgotten if he Draws Roadmap for Congress' Sunlit Future
By Prabhu Chawla | Published: 25th May 2014 06:00 AM |
The ides of May have brought low India’s pre-eminent dynasty. But will the line of Caesar continue long enough in politics to bring the Congress party deliverance from damnation? India has decisively rejected the Congress, an outfit owned and controlled by the Gandhis since 1998. If in 2004, the dynasty re-asserted its appeal by dethroning the NDA government led by the hugely popular Atal Bihari Vajpayee, in 2014 Hurricane Modi mauled it beyond recognition. Success has many fathers, but failure is always an orphan, shunted around in the hope of finding a convenient lap—an exercise happening currently in the 125-year-old Congress. Patrons of the Manmohan Singh government are holding mother and son responsible for the party’s abysmal rout, choosing to forget that it was India’s weakest ever Prime Minister who customised a grave for the Congress by leading an indecisive and tainted administration. Manmohan will go down in history as the unreturnable prodigal who hobbled his political materfamilias, who had elevated him from a mere Babu to the CEO of a 1.2-billion strong nation.
The Manmohan era is an unforgettably dismal chapter in Congress history. The party failed to even win enough seats to claim the position of the leader of the opposition. Its total tally of 44 MPs is just half the number of seats the BJP won from Uttar Pradesh and Bihar alone. The Congress won only one seat within the 325 km radius of the capital—Haryana Chief Minister’s son Deepinder Hooda’s. But instead of focusing on the UPA government’s lame legacy, the savage spotlight is on Rahul Gandhi alone. From corporate leaders to TV’s speaking classes, Rahul is seen as the only fall guy for the party’s pathetic performance. He is accused of depending on foreign-educated technocrats, ignoring Congress grassroots workers and being totally inaccessible to even senior leaders. Undoubtedly, he was the playing captain of his team, pitched against a supremely aggressive Modi riding an unprecedented popularity tsunami. Rahul’s campaign style was confused. He lacked a clear focus. He just kept parroting lines about work done by the government, insentient of the popular hatred towards it. According to Congress sources, he chose an ad agency which was clueless about Indian political idiom and grammar. He had neither a credible message nor an effective medium to influence the verdict. To give new players executive campaign experience, he picked leaders like Jairam Ramesh and Madhusudan Mistry to manage elections in crucial states like Uttar Pradesh and Andhra Pradesh. They lacked even a preliminary knowledge of local equations and issues. In other states too, unknown and untested leaders were sent to fight the Might of Modi.
The knives are out for Rahul. Predictably, most of the Gandhi loyalists have come forward in his defence. But now, apart from accepting responsibility, Rahul also has to ensure accountability not only for his performance but of others as well. He has been in politics for a decade and in office for the past three years. The storm of 2014 has made it abundantly clear that the Gandhi name is no longer the password for a successful entry into the corridors of power. Both Rahul and Sonia are experiencing the phase of diminishing returns. The Congress has been a meal ticket party and if the Gandhis are unable to deliver, it will only shrink further. Rahul can’t get away with excuses such as he hasn’t been allowed absolute freedom to jettison deadwood in the party. Even his admirers feel that if he has to reclaim acceptability, he must take complete charge or get discharged. Since age is on his side, he can take chances an older leader can’t even think of doing. Congressmen expect Rahul to shed the image of a shoot-and-scoot politician who appears on stage and vanishes after delivering random punches. Now he has enough time to reinvent not just himself but also create a new Congress, which can fight as an effective opposition. His mother brought the Congress to power by compromising with regional satraps. His challenge is to get rid of most of them. Like fair-weather birds, most of the Gandhi Parivar’s former and current allies have started dumping it. Rahul started the Revive Congress Operation from UP five years ago and was credited with sweeping 22 Lok Sabha seats. But he failed miserably in the state Assembly elections both in UP and Bihar later. His real test now lies in his ability to ensure that the national status of the Congress remains. Though it rules in over a dozen states, it represents less than 15 per cent of the Indian population and 25 per cent of the total seats. Barring Karnataka, the Congress does not run any large state. Its base started shrinking first in late 1979 when it lost political space to Dravidian parties in Tamil Nadu. After that, it started losing out in West Bengal, Odisha, Bihar, UP, and also the smaller states. If Verdict 2014 is repeated during the state elections in Maharashtra, the party may not be able to earn the status of the leader of the opposition ever. For Rahul, the task is cut out. He faces the major challenge of replacing the reigning fossils of Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, Punjab, West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh and Bihar. Earlier, frontal organisations like the Mahila Congress, Youth Congress, labour and students’ outfits were major founts of strength for the Congress revival. Under Rahul’s leadership, neither did any of these grow nor did they make any impact on the election outcome. A study of over 300 Congress office-bearers of the AICC and PCCs reveals that over 70 per cent are either from various political clans or have never fought an election. The wrong people have captured the positions of power in the party. Rahul’s survival is tenuously linked with the aptitude to hone his communicative skills, the ability to define his vision, the authority to dump the derelicts and hardly working sycophants and promote the hard-working. His inglorious political past will only be forgotten if he can draw a roadmap along with his sister for a sunlit future of the Congress.
Follow him on Twitter @PrabhuChawla