STOCK MARKET BSE NSE

With huge fines on telecom companies, India hangs up on the future

The Supreme Court has now ordered the companies to pay the government not just the dues but a hefty penalty - as well interest on both.

Published: 30th October 2019 03:51 PM  |   Last Updated: 30th October 2019 03:51 PM   |  A+A-

Telecom companies Bharti Airtel, Vodafone Idea and Reliance Jio.

Telecom companies Bharti Airtel, Vodafone Idea and Reliance Jio. (File Photos)

Bloomberg

India's growth this century has been fuelled by one sector above all: telecommunications. The connectivity revolution has powered India's information technology behemoths and helped hundreds of millions of young Indians get onto the grid, giving them a chance to improve their prospects.

If India is to become the sort of entrepreneurial superstar that its government hopes it will, then the telecom sector is obviously going to be central to that plan.

So why does the Indian state seem determined to push telecom businesses into crushing debt and possible bankruptcy, instead of ensuring the sector remains healthy and competitive? This week, one of India's three remaining large telecom companies, Bharti Airtel Ltd, postponed the announcement of its financial results for the last quarter.

ALSO READ: Airtel defers September quarter results till November 14 

This isn't good news, given that in the quarter ending in June 2019 it reported a loss for the first time ever. Bloomberg's average of analysts' expectations from the quarter ending in September is that the company will lose 14 billion rupees, almost US$200 million (S$272.5 million).

Bharti Airtel is a key associate of Singtel, which has a 35.2 per cent stake in the Indian telco. Singtel saw its net profit for the three months to June 30 plunge on the back of regional associates' results, including a $162.2 million loss at Bharti Airtel.

The immediate reason for the delay is clear: a recent Supreme Court judgment that ordered Bharti Airtel and other legacy telecom companies, including Vodafone Idea Ltd, to pay billions of dollars to the government.

ALSO READ: Airtel delays results as it seeks 'support' from government over Rs 42,000 crore statutory levies​

The decision sprang from a long-running dispute between the sector and the state on how to calculate the government's share of revenue, which it receives as part of the fee for handing over the telecommunications spectrum. The companies argued that only their revenue from the use of spectrum should count; the government wanted a share of everything including, for example, revenue from rent.

The Supreme Court has now ordered the companies to pay the government not just the dues but a hefty penalty - as well interest on both. The total amount the companies owe approaches US$13 billion. Vodafone Idea owes US$4 billion of that, Bharti Airtel around US$3 billion.

The companies are supposed to pay up in three months, though it's far from certain how that's possible. They're already snowed under with debt - thanks, in large part, to the Indian state.

ALSO READ: Supreme Court orders Telecom companies to clear dues worth Rs 92,000 crore​

Vodafone Idea's debt in March 2019 was US$14 billion; Airtel's was over US$15 billion. Some of that debt burden is thanks to the exorbitant amount they've already shelled out for spectrum. The government changed an earlier policy that subsidized spectrum to one involving auctions that would maximize the amount that it receives as revenue - great news for the drafters of the budget, bad news for investors in the sector and overall growth.

It doesn't help that the sector's caught in a bruising price war thanks to a cash-rich new entrant: Reliance Jio Infocomm Ltd, which can call upon the massive war chest of petrochemicals major Reliance Industries Ltd.

Jio's two rivals have long accused it of receiving favourable regulatory decisions, such as one that allowed 4G spectrum that had been assigned for data to be used for voice services as well. Jio's entry into the market has been great news for Indian consumers, who now get high-speed data at some of the lowest rates in the world. But it means that Jio's already heavily burdened competitors may go under.

ALSO READ: Airtel asks Centre to review Supreme Court order's impact on telecom dues 

The government now says it will convene a panel of senior bureaucrats to consider how to ease financial stress among telecom companies. Yet, this comes after it's attempted to squeeze every last rupee out of the sector to pay for spectrum, imposed adverse regulation and then appealed legal decisions all the way to the Supreme Court.

Moreover, the government is also planning to spend US$6 billion to revive moribund state-owned telecom companies and assign them 4G spectrum at an "administrative" cost. The price war will now include not just deep-pocketed Jio but the even deeper pockets of the Indian state.

There's no point making the laissez-faire argument and shrugging one's shoulders if Vodafone Idea and Bharti Airtel shut down. It's hard to see why any new investors would want to enter a market in which the playing field is so uneven.

Besides, past investors have already been burnt by state action: Norway's Telenor ASA, the UAE's Emirates Telecommunications Group Co. PJSC and Russia's Sistema PJSFC wrote off investments worth about US$2.5 billion after the Supreme Court cancelled licences en masse a few years ago, following corruption allegations that have not been upheld by the courts.

Foreign investors will also note that they can't even appeal to international arbitration anymore since the Indian government unilaterally cancelled the investment treaties that made that possible. Investment by existing operators into the new infrastructure that could power India's future - such as 5G - looks unlikely in the near future. 

India's statist politicians seem to assume that every sector is a cash cow for their welfarism, and that foreign investors can't quit India. They had better think again. Aviation has already been decimated by state action; it looks like telecom is next, in spite of the fact that it is the backbone of any realistic growth strategy for India. The government's boasts about improving the ease of doing business in India, or of being a magnet for investment, ring awfully hollow given how hard politicians are making it for healthy, competitive markets to survive.



Comments

Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the newindianexpress.com editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on newindianexpress.com are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of newindianexpress.com or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. newindianexpress.com reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp