Amritsar train tragedy: Explaining why loco pilot failed to stop train

TNIE spoke to an electric loco pilot to learn and find out how and when a loco pilot stops the train and why the train was not stopped at the accident spot.

Published: 23rd October 2018 08:08 PM  |   Last Updated: 20th January 2020 04:20 PM   |  A+A-

Loco pilot applies brakes to control or to reduce speed based on warnings or by watching signals. (Photo | Facebook)

Loco pilot applies brakes to control or to reduce speed based on warnings or by watching signals.(Photo | Facebook)

Online Desk

On Dussehra, a huge crowd of Dussehra revelers was watching a Ravan effigy go up in flames amid exploding firecrackers at Jora Phatak in Amritsar. Many of them spilled on to the nearby elevated railway tracks for a better view before the Jalandhar-Amritsar DMU passenger train heading to Hoshiarpur came hurtling down the same tracks at 7 p.m. Getting on to the tracks proved fatal as more than 60 Dussehra revelers were crushed to death on the tracks.

READ | Amritsar train accident: Dussehra event organiser cries, says he warned crowd 10 times about railway track

Railways came under scrutiny following the incident as scores of people staged a sit-in on railway tracks demanding action against officials including the loco pilot. They alleged that the loco pilot did not stop the speeding train to avoid the mayhem.

READ | Amritsar train tragedy: Worst accident caused by trespassing in the history of railways

TNIE spoke to SP Sahu, an electric loco pilot (Rajdhani/ Shatabdi) who is also General Secretary of East Central Railway Employees Union (ECREU) and asked the following questions to find out how and when a loco pilot stops the train and why it could not be in this instance.

When does a loco pilot apply brakes?

Loco pilot applies brakes to control or to reduce speed based on warnings or by watching signals.

When are the emergency brakes applied?

Emergency brakes are applied when the train needs to be stopped at once. Such conditions include loco pilot finding the tracks being uprooted or spotting any other fault with the tracks.

How much distance does a train cover when emergency brake is applied?

It depends on the length of the train. If the emergency brake is applied to a 24-coach train running at the speed of 100km/hr, it covers 700-900 metres before coming to a halt. In a fully-loaded goods train, it takes 1100-1300 metres.

Inside view of electric locomotive. (Photo | Facebook)

The Amritsar train would have needed to cover at least 600 metres before stopping after the loco pilot applied the brake (as it was a small diesel-propelled train). It works the same way when someone pulls the emergency chain inside the train.

In case of any sudden obstruction, why don't the loco pilots stop the train?

Loco drivers don’t hit or crush someone intentionally. It happens because they don’t get enough braking distance. It also depends on visibility as in daytime there is better visibility than at night. While visibility is around 1000-1200 metres during the day, it gets reduced to only 100-200 metres during night depending on the engine headlight.

Will application of emergency brake result in the derailing of a train?

This is a common myth that a train might derail when the emergency brake is applied. A train derails only when there is a fault with the wheels or with the railway track or wagon or some other technical fault.

Could the loco pilot have prevented the Amritsar train accident?

Vivek Kumar, Divisional Railway Manager, Ferozpur, said the railways had already questioned the loco pilot and found that there was no lapse on his part. He said the train was travelling at a speed of 91 km/hr, but after spotting the crowd on the track, he could only slow it down to 68 km/hr.

The above explanation clarifies why he could not have averted the accident.


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

  • Jatin

    Anirudh bro
    3 years ago reply
  • aman verma

    Railways is a billion dollar organization when it gives such phony explanations when even toy cars are coming that will detect a wall using sonar technology. Railways looks like an impostor. Give me 40
    3 years ago reply
  • Lunarboi

    Retards celebrating on train tracks. What were they expecting ? This isn't a tragedy for those people
    3 years ago reply
  • sandhu

    our society is mad and law breakers
    3 years ago reply

    My only answer to the Amritsar Train incident tragedy is the failure of entire system of government machinery. If the report in media true than why the local police are not sensitize enough for such an event which is organised since last many years near the Railway track. Further why the administration machinery like District Collector of the Area or the lower officer did not bother to check the arrangements before the event. Again is railway authority of the said area are informed earlier about such event and request are come from organiser for slow of trains or any other methods to avoid such type of tragedy. These are the major issues to be highlighted.
    3 years ago reply
  • Muralidharan

    It is the event security personal who are responsible for the tragedy. Railways has no say in this. As the train was travelling at 91 kmph
    3 years ago reply
  • Hiralal

    Why are they beating about the Bush. People who were standing or equating on the railway track are solely to blame. The organisers or the police should have cautioned them or removed them.
    3 years ago reply
  • amarnath

    It is not possible to stop the train by locopilot as he wishes at any point of time. He has to first slow down and apply brakes. Otherwise it will become a major accident killing all travellers. Only ignorant people talk like this. If caution message had been given
    3 years ago reply
flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp