Vande Bharat beats China, COVID

Why were economic realities never a factor in India’s relations with China? Lazy India became dependent on hardworking China for even everyday items.

Published: 02nd August 2020 07:04 AM  |   Last Updated: 02nd August 2020 11:14 AM   |  A+A-

India China Flag

China and India flags (Photo | AFP)

India’s view of, and dealings with, China are becoming curiouser and curiouser. Suddenly, we are told that dozens of Chinese apps have been banned. Reasons cited include security and privacy. How come these became issues only now? For long China, like all other topics, has been a provider of opportunities for our Prime Minister to display his showmanship; remember his donning South Indian veshti and angavastram for a meeting with Xi Jinping? All that is forgotten now.

About two months ago, our Government decided to put import restrictions on Chinese goods. More recently, some 200 proposals China had put forward for investment were held up for “security clearance”. After the Ladakh clash that killed 20 Indian soldiers, these were seen as political-strategic moves. Why were economic realities never a factor in India’s relations with China?  Lazy India became dependent on hardworking China for even everyday items.

Consider the situation that developed as a result of this approach. Our smartphone market is dominated by China. The “Made in India” tag on some phones is a patriotic lie; it only means “assembled” in India. Radial tyres for trucks, power equipment, electronic components for the metros in our big cities, all come from China.  Why? Even if this is understandable to some extent, why is it that our Ganesh idols have to be imported from China? Why do our Diwali crackers come from China?

This rather humiliating situation should have woken up our leaders long ago. But there are some hard realities behind the slumber. Perhaps the most noteworthy is the cleverness with which China massaged our ego and diverted our attention. Look at its almost unnatural interest in Gujarat. Its investments in Gujarat in the last five years add up to an impressive Rs 43,000 crore.  The Chinese association of small and medium enterprises has secured the contract for an industrial plant in Dholera smart city. Its Great Wall Motors Company has drawn up plans to invest Rs 7,000 crore in a mega vehicle manufacturing plant in Gujarat. Other Chinese enterprises have also got involved in various projects in Gujarat.

Which leader from Gujarat would fail to notice with appreciation this level of interest by a foreign country? To drive it further home, the shrewd Chinese picked some politically important platforms for special consideration. Through popular smartphone companies like Oppo and Xiaomi, they gave Rs 49 crore to PM-CARES fund which, as of now, is not subject to any auditing systems in the country. They also drew up plans to set up a Chinatown in Gujarat. (Chinatowns are cultural magnets with which the Chinese attract people across the world. The Chinatowns in New York and San Francisco are living bits of China’s heart with which local people identify in toto.)

Chineseness has another characteristic that is unique. While Indians in London try to become as English as the English, the Chinese remain Chinese inside and outside. What is part of their culture they will never shed. Their notions about India with which they have problems of the bristling kind, are deeply entrenched. India has learned that China is a hard bargainer, unused to yielding even an inch as it expects others to yield a yard.

Add to this, their latent disdain for Indians. They have disdain for all non-Chinese though they do not show it. With India they don’t mind showing a bit of it. A recent Facebook post by a Chinese citizen was typical. “Even if Chinese people want to boycott Indian products, they can’t really find many Indian goods. Indian friends, you need to have some things that are more important than nationalism.”

Obviously. he was aware of India’s dependence on China even for toys and drugs. So what do we do? Switching to the US will be a fool’s errand. Our great nationalist leaders should ask why India is in a situation where it has to depend either on China or on the US to sustain itself. They are ever boastful about India’s capabilities, but they don’t seem to know how to promote domestic enterprise so that we don’t have to be at the mercy of others for our everyday needs.

Perhaps, the mistake is with observers like me — that we do not see things in the right perspective.  Perhaps, the only fact that matters is that our Prime Minister is strong and his Government is firmly entrenched, that he has got COVID and Galwan under his grip and that the sun is shining bright. A mild Vande Bharat shout will be in order. 

Stay up to date on all the latest T J S George news with The New Indian Express App. Download now


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

  • Priyabrata

    You spoke my mind. Thanks!
    7 days ago reply
  • krish

    Instead of just finding fault with all that that is Indian
    8 days ago reply

    der aaye
    8 days ago reply
  • sridhar

    be judicious in hiring writers too.
    8 days ago reply
  • anon

    great article!
    8 days ago reply
flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp