STOCK MARKET BSE NSE

The world may be sorry for India

More than any other Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi longed for international approbation.

Published: 07th February 2021 07:37 AM  |   Last Updated: 07th February 2021 07:44 AM   |  A+A-

PM Narendra Modi

PM Narendra Modi (Photo | AP)

More than any other Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi longed for international approbation. He wanted the world to chant Howdy Modi not as part of an organised publicity stunt, but spontaneously with love and reverence. Power in India was important, but just as important was admiration by the world. It was important that the world understood how a tide of popularity carried him to the top and how continuing applause by an ecstatic people is keeping him there. The expensively organised Houston triumph has faded out of memory. Today Modi is a target of attack from many quarters across the world. The world finally saw that his was a communal approach to policy making.

The current farmers’ agitation and Modi’s handling of it have invited further resentment. Not surprisingly, the marching farmers have received considerable support from many countries because of their orderly behaviour. The biggest tactical mistake made by the BJP was to describe foreign critics as Khalistanis. The fundamentalist Sikh separatist movement that sought to establish an independent nation in Punjab never gained traction in India.

By dismissing critics as Khalistanis, Modi and his backers only weakened their own position. The Government’s stance is that its policies are based on three relevant Acts passed by Parliament. This may be technically correct. But the way the Bills were passed was seen by all as questionable. When the opposition called for a counting of votes in the Rajya Sabha, the Deputy Chairman passed the law by using a voice vote. His judgment was that one side had shouted louder than the other. In any case, the Government had taken the ordinance route to “regulate” the agricultural front. Parliament is used when it is convenient to do so; when it is not, it is sidestepped.

The farmers attracted widespread support in India and abroad, primarily, for two reasons — the reasonableness of their demands and the peaceful nature of their campaign. Strangely, the Government pretended not to see any problem anywhere. This went on until Republic Day when the farmers, their ranks swelled by delegates from many states, staged a march. That was more than what the authorities could tolerate. Agents of the Government went into action eventually leading to the deployment of teargas and water cannons. The farmers still refused to give up. In a climbdown managed not to look like one, the Modi Government offered to suspend the laws for two years.

There was no mention of what would happen after two years. The Government’s argument that the new laws would give farmers more freedom convinced no one. The farmers knew that the new laws would drive prices down for their produce and that they would also be threatened by corporate takeovers. As one specialist put it: “The political side is that this Government has been very autocratic in the way in which it has pushed through big reform.” The world must be feeling sorry about what has overtaken India. It must be a new experience for Modi to feel defied and devalued.

The days are gone when he could mesmerise people with his oratory. Now, people want not big words dramatically delivered, but beneficial reforms effectively introduced. Modi could not have failed to notice the dignity with which the marching farmers conducted themselves. They politely refused food that was offered to them, preferring to cook their own in the midst of their march.

The great Amit Shah was nowhere to be seen; he probably understood that this was an arena where his games would not get anywhere. This a country where about 12,000 farmers commit suicide in a year. Debts they cannot repay, crops that fail, calculations that go wrong — there are many reasons that drive them into desperation. Such devastating facts make no impression even on those who run our Parliament. Many MPs demanded a debate on the farmers’ issues.

Such a debate in the kind of situation that has developed would have been the right thing to do. That’s what Parliament is for. But not in today’s India. The Government refused to agree to a debate, thereby exposing its own untenable position. No debate, no discussion, no explanation. What the Government does, it does. Who are the people to ask? This was not what was intended by the Constitution makers. That it has come to this juncture points to the fall of India under Narendra Modi.


TAGS
Howdy Modi

Comments(9)

Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the newindianexpress.com editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on newindianexpress.com are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of newindianexpress.com or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. newindianexpress.com reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

  • Ramsurya

    Making generalisations without justifying those stands
    23 days ago reply
  • Puneet

    What is amazing is that the people who have nothing to do farmers are now part of farmers protest supporting the farmers. And the people like these writer whose only aim is to oppose whatever the govt is doing by peddling fake news. And the funny thing in this digital age everyone knows where every one stands. All these so called journalists and so called farmers are in one team now with one anti govt agenda..
    24 days ago reply
  • fajesh

    Selectively choosing to exclude details that will severely weaken your argument
    24 days ago reply
  • Jawahar Thadhani

    This is the beginning of the end for Modi Shah and the BJP.Modi is a nassacist and loves attention.He has started acting like a dictator and forcing his dictat down peoples throat. Like Trump he will fall soon. His Hinduvata will not work with Sikhs
    25 days ago reply
  • Tushar Deshpande

    Come on TJS
    25 days ago reply
  • a.k.sehanobis

    Well
    25 days ago reply
  • Ramesh Mishra

    INDIA The world is not sorry for India-the world is afraid of India in 2021
    25 days ago reply
  • Ganesh Shenoy

    Wonderful piece by George sir that chronicles the unmasking and fall of Modi!
    25 days ago reply
  • Satya Nayak

    Who are these misleading columnists? its better if they keep their opinions to themselves
    25 days ago reply
flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp