NEW DELHI: Desperately pleading for release, Swami Shraddhananda —serving 30 years jail sentence without remission for killing his wife—on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that the imprisonment till his biological death awarded to him is far worse than the capital punishment.
“You want your jail sentence to be changed to hanging,” a surprised court asked him. A bench headed by Justice B R Gavai was hearing a review petition filed by 84-year-old Shraddhananda alias Murali Manohar Mishra, seeking reconsideration of a judgment which imposed on him a life sentence (without remission) for the murder of his wife Shakereh Khaleeli (granddaughter of Dewan of Mysore, Sir Mirza Ismail).
Although Justice Gavai refused his writ petition seeking release from jail, he agreed to hear his separate plea seeking review of the apex court’s July 2008 verdict, which had directed that he be imprisoned for the rest of his life.
The top court refused Shraddhananda’s request that he be allowed to decide his jail sentence. “It is not a convict’s right to decide his or her jail sentence,” the apex court said.
Shraddananda sought relief from the top court because he has been in “continuous incarceration” without any parole or remission so far with no adverse reports against him during his stay in jail. He claimed that he is suffering from health issues and should be released.
The trial court and the High Court had sentenced him to death, but in 2008, the Supreme Court commuted it to imprisonment until death.
Shraddhanand, seeking a direction for his release, said that the sentence imposed on him was, in some terms, worse than a death sentence. What is the purpose of the state infusing funds to keep him in jail if he never comes out? The apex court issued notice to respondents on Shraddananda’s plea and decided to hear the matter later.
Also in top court
‘Gram Nyayalayas to help improve justice’
The Supreme Court said establishment of Gram Nyayalayas across the country would help litigants get improved access to justice. The petitioner, NGO, National Federation of Societies For Fast Justice, had moved the apex court seeking a direction to the Centre and all states for taking steps to set up ‘Gram Nyayalayas’.
NMC expected to act fair: Top court
National Medical Commission (NMC) is an organ of the state and is expected to act in a fair and reasonable manner, the Supreme Court has said recently, while dismissing with costs of `10 lakh its pleas challenging an order of the Kerala HC. It was on withdrawal of approval to a medical college for increase of seats.