Modi-Shah blunder over Lakshadweep

Our leaders have a special talent to turn peaceful landscapes into war zones.

Published: 30th May 2021 06:43 AM  |   Last Updated: 30th May 2021 11:52 AM   |  A+A-

Union minister Amit Shah (L) and Lakshadweep administrator Praful Patel

Union minister Amit Shah (L) and Lakshadweep administrator Praful Patel. (Photo| EPS)

Our leaders have a special talent to turn peaceful landscapes into war zones. Remember how, one fine morning, Jammu & Kashmir was divided into two Union territories. As if on signal, Mukesh Ambani formed a task force and said "You'll see several steps for J&K, Ladakh soon."

We are about to see several steps for Lakshadweep soon. As per tradition, Lakshadweep's administrator was a bureaucrat from the IAS/IPS ranks. When Dineshwar Sharma, who was chief of the Intelligence Bureau before he took over as Administrator of Lakshadweep, died in December 2020, the Government of India broke tradition and appointed a friendly politico. (Friendly to the Government, that is). He lost no time in turning things upside down. Even to send a sick person to a hospital in the mainland, his approval became necessary.

That came naturally to Praful Khoda Patel because the plus point in his favour was that his father was an RSS leader. Patel served as Gujarat's Home Minister under Modi. His political career ended when he failed to get elected in 2012. Modi gave him a new life by appointing him Administrator of Dadra and Haveli.

All the psychological complexes he developed as a failed politician now came to haunt Lakshadweepians. Perhaps, the RSS soul in him could not reconcile with the fact that the entire population of Lakshadweep was Muslim. Three per cent were listed as non-Muslim, but these were not locals; they were itinerant traders from the mainland. Patel must have resented this. With his experience confined to putting administrative power to political use, Patel acted like a local dictator. Some 200 high school teachers were dismissed because they were on contract. Students who protested were disciplined with lathis. As many as 190 people were dismissed from the tourism department. Subdivisional magistrates in various islands were also dismissed. Hindi-speaking officers from North India were put in charge, knowing that locals knew only their native dialects and Malayalam.

The zilla panchayat was made virtually powerless, with the Administrator assuming all responsibilities. In the name of coastal protection laws, the fishing community's nets and sheds were taken away. Two functioning dairy farms were closed, saying that they were running at a loss. Orders were issued to sell off the cattle at the rate of Rs 250 per kilo. Milk arrived by ship from Gujarat.

Traditionally, Lakshadweep's trading activities were conducted through Beypore Port in Kozhikode district. The new dispensation put an end to the practice and ordered that Mangalore Port be used instead. Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan said bluntly that Lakshadweep had strong and age-old links with Kerala in education, employment, medical services and trade and that secretive attempts to break this were underway. CPM state secretary A Vijayaraghavan put it in stronger terms. The Government was interfering, he said, even in the food habits of the locals. He saw Delhi’s policies as an attempt to convert Lakshadweep into an experimental ground of Hindutva politics. Even the BJP unit in Lakshadweep joined the chorus of protestors.

The power of sentiment showed its worth in the words of Zabith, a resident of the islands. She said: "From the time of my great grandmother, we have been living in this house. If Lakshadweep Development Authority Regulation comes into force, I will need their permission to live here for more than three years. Protests are not taking place because of COVID protocol."

If that was a personalised response to the situation that developed, a principle-based perspective was provided by CPM’s A Vijayaraghavan. Noting that "the Government interferes even in food traditions (read, beef consumption) of local residents", he said: "What is happening is a dastardly attempt to convert Lakshadweep into an experimental ground for Hindutva Politics."

How far Hindutva politics can go when confronted by Malayali politics is unsure. It is a state where the BJP has failed to gain a foothold. Even the best efforts of a manipulator like Praful Patel will not find it easy to break Malayali cultural barricades. That won’t bother him of course. In his home state itself, he is known as an operator who is not interested in what people think of him. He is trusted by Modi and Amit Shah, and that is all that matters to him.

This is actually a tragedy of Modi and Shah. They do not understand the grassroots feelings of people. Otherwise, they would have seen the importance of what Lakshadweep PCC president Hamdullah Sayeed said: "Those who have more than two children are disqualified from contesting panchayat elections. With this democracy has become meaningless."

So, for a great many people, has the Modi-Shah leadership.


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

  • Dev

    How brazenly these leftist media ignore the fact that (a) china is increasingly a threat in Indian ocean (b) 15 of the church-bomb massacre terrorists are moslems who escaped to lakshadweep. Have to say anything more on the new Goonda act? India media is cold out. Long live NAMO.
    1 year ago reply
  • GujjuMal

    write by writing: "Our leaders have a special talent to turn peaceful landscapes into war zones" referring to his leader Pappu?
    1 year ago reply
  • Sundar

    Why taking corrective measures is always questioned? Let them do it for India safety
    1 year ago reply
  • Shahzada

    Isn’t this apartheid racial and religious discrimination. All Modo Shah and Patel shall be tried in international court or if they get away then they will be tried by God they believe in
    1 year ago reply
  • Shoby P Jose

    Goonda Act for a region with the lowest crime rate in India(almost zero).2)Banning of cow slaughter & beef products for a population almost 100% beef eating.3)Liqour,not consumed by its inhabitants,to be rammed down their throat.4)maximum 2 children criterion not a law in India,although illegally implemented in the Gujarat local body elections sought to be made a law here.5)Lakshawadeep with total area of just about 36 sq.kms(most islands are almost as small as a few 100 metres in length)cannot ecologically withstand even two storeyed bulidlngs(forget about large aircrafts for its only airport & highways.Connected to India from the Kochi seaport & airport only. The agenda is loud & clear-to facilitate the region only for tourism by displacing the local population of around 70,000 & hand them on a platter to the Ambanis & the Adanis(corporate leeches)
    1 year ago reply
  • Burnol supplier

    Article writer pls apply some burnol.. haha
    1 year ago reply
  • Romesh Chander Garg

    This is an elected Government and whatever she is doing ,it is for their and India's betterment. Negative media is always against the good deeds of India
    1 year ago reply
  • anthony

    The Lakshadweep Administrator is only furthering the agenda of the RSS and the divisive policies of Modi and Amit Shah. Quite possible some of these measures may have been at the behest of their Cronies Ambani and Adani. The only way to pressurise all of them at this stage is to Boycott all the products of Ambani and Adani and deliver Massive Electrol losses like in Bengal and Tamilnadu.
    1 year ago reply
  • Charles Martel

    Nothing wrong in putting birth control on these guys.
    1 year ago reply
  • sree kumar. N

    Now people like T J S George became meaningless and irrelevant.They only see one part.
    1 year ago reply
  • Ravi Krishnamoorty

    George if I have to know the meaning of white lies just sufficient to read.your piece.
    1 year ago reply
flipboard facebook twitter whatsapp