The Supreme Court in Delhi. (File Photo | PTI)
India

SC pulls up Centre for ignoring order on benefits to disabled officer cadets

The Bench said the Centre's latest affidavit showed no genuine reconsideration of the recommendations of the 2015 Sabharwal Committee despite its August 4, 2026 order.

Suchitra Kalyan Mohanty

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Wednesday said the Centre was showing "scant attitude" towards its direction to reconsider benefits for officer cadets who become disabled during military training.

A Bench comprising Justices B V Nagarathna, R Mahadevan and D K Upadhyaya was hearing the suo motu case initiated to address lack of status, pensionary benefits and rehabilitation support for such cadets.

The court on August 4, 2026 had directed the Centre to reconsider recommendations of the 2015 Sabharwal Committee report favourably.

The Bench on Wednesday expressed dissatisfaction over Centre's affidavit, noting no genuine reconsideration despite clear direction. The affidavit merely referred to meetings held in 2022 and extracted earlier decisions rejecting disability pension and ESM status for outboarded cadets. There was "no whisper" that Sabharwal Committee recommendations were reconsidered after court's intervention.

"What is this scant attitude you (Centre) are showing to the court? You say we disposed it of in 2022 and there ends the matter. What is the attitude on the part of the department,?" the bench observed.

Justice Mahadevan noted key recommendation relating to disability pension not revisited. "Pursuant to our 4th August direction, there is no reconsideration," he said.

The court observed ordinary recruits boarded out receive disability pension and benefits, while officer cadets - whose numbers are small, around 400 over many years or 40 per year - are denied.

Amicus Curiae Senior Advocate Rekha Palli submitted that the cadets seek parity.

ASG Aishwarya Bhati for the Centre maintained granting ESM status or disability pension at officer rates not feasible under existing policy.

Hearing these submissions, Justice Nagarathna pressed and suggesyed the Centre to at least cover educational expenses for diploma-level courses to improve future employment prospects.

In its order, the bench recorded non-compliance of August 4 direction, directed Centre to hold proper meeting, reconsider recommendations, place minutes on record, warning non-compliance could lead to adverse orders including mandamus. Amicus was asked to identify benefits currently extended to boarded-out recruit soldiers so comparable facilities for officer cadets could be examined.

Pak minister seeks India's invitation for talks on Indus Waters Treaty, avoids questions on past threat

Bengaluru police stop YS Sharmila from visiting Yelahanka property over court injunction

SpiceJet gets a massive thumbs down from flyers in survey

Hyderabad on alert as alleged LeT email warns of 26/11 repeat, threatens to kill 300 people

‘Anti-Hindu, anti-Sanatan’: BJP attacks TN government over SC review plea on Thiruparankundram Deepam