Wards being set up at Madurai Government Rajaji Hospital  (Photo | Express)
Opinion

Blueprint for viksit healthcare

Private healthcare in India is consolidating like never before. But much of the country still depends on the public system and remains outside insurance cover. The law regulating clinical establishments must be expanded and the healthcare system opened up to community audits

Dr K R Antony

Wooing venture capitalists to invest in both the health and insurance businesses can be seen as a moral scandal for a country as impoverished as India. Can our self-image of development afford to be one where cities are dotted with posh multi-storeyed hospitals housing world-class health businesses to cater only to the rich and generate enormous profits?

The recent mergers and acquisitions of a number of hospitals by foreign private equity and wealth funds have consolidated India’s private healthcare sector, lessening competition that keeps prices in check and players on their toes, and creating large corporatised chains focused on profits. Such takeovers have been reported from Kerala, Telangana, Maharashtra and West Bengal, among others. The wave has spread to tier 2 and 3 cities, too.

This is no criticism of private healthcare, which may help improve efficiency and provide services public-funded institutions lack in a particular geography. But we must look closer at the drivers for such a shift in a country where large sections still depend on State-run facilities. 

The topmost driver of corporatisation is high unmet demand for tertiary care. The Indian middle class wants a standard of living that’s comparable to that in rich nations. They want a matching medical care, too. Not surprisingly, the 80th Round of Household Consumption Survey on health noted a significant proportion of people going to the private sector. The last three survey rounds also show a rise in the use public healthcare facilities in rural India.

In corporate hospitals, profit is paramount. Return on investment is the primary operational goal, not client satisfaction. Healing as an ethical service can take a backseat. The top executives check billing and set targets, especially for high-margin procedures like robotic surgeries and assisted reproductive technologies. It matters what proportion of patients come under the knife. As the Supreme Court has recently noted, this leads to rampant overbilling, and unnecessary costly procedures and laboratory tests. It’s no wonder that the average expenses at private hospitals have increased by 70 percent in rural areas and 80 percent in urban areas over eight years.

The public-private disparity continues in out-of-pocket medical expenditure per hospitalisation (excluding childbirths). According to the latest government survey, such expenses in private hospitals were 7.5 times that in public ones, whereas the median expense exceeded 10-folds. These continue to be significant due to shortage of medicines, diagnostic services and high transport and other non-medical costs.

Insurance often fails to cover these deductibles. Genuine outpatient consultations and medications are denied as the insurance claim-settlement ratio falls. False claims and unnecessary investigations are both on the rise. 

The resultant trauma and financial crisis can be mitigated by making the public health system more robust. While insurance coverage has increased considerably compared to previous health survey rounds, this has not translated into a significant rise in the use of hospital care. 

Currently, less than half rural and urban households are covered by some form of health insurance, mainly by government-financed insurance schemes. Only 13 percent of those in rural and 9 percent in urban India claim hospitalisation services under these schemes. Women in agricultural, construction, sanitation and home-based production are largely unregistered. 

Entrusting the private sector to safeguard the interest of the poor is a utopia. Competition among private providers may also not lower prices adequately for most consumers. That’s why medical crises often leads to debt traps for families.

The Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010—which registers and regulates all public and private clinical establishments to establish minimum standards for facilities, services and care—is implemented only in 11 states and most Union territories. The main opponents to its expansion were private hospital chains and the Indian Medical Association. During the Covid pandemic, legal fights resulted in reimbursement of excess billed amounts. Capping the trade margins on devices, implants, prosthesis and investigative procedures and imaging might help. The reduction of costs of pacemakers and stents by governmental intervention gives us hope.

Recently, a parliamentary committee recommended benchmarking basic room charges of private hospitals in metropolitan cities against the average tariff of nearby three-star hotels. That too remains on a page of yet another report.

Democratic governments must withstand the pressure brought about by powerful lobbies in creating a deeply unequal care system and ensure equity in welfare.

It is time to rethink the insurance-led model and refocus on strengthening public healthcare to deliver universal, comprehensive care. The model of having Ayushman Arogya Mandirs or health and wellness centres at the periphery, referral to community centres for secondary care, and district hospital or medical colleges for tertiary care still holds good. Let corporate hospitals for tertiary care be an option for the rich—not a necessity for certain serious illnesses or advanced tests.  

India’s health system has been remodelled based on the lessons learnt. What is needed today is to strengthen it with managerial efficiency, transparency, quality monitoring and social audit through wider community participation. That will be a fitting image for viksit healthcare.

Dr K R Antony | Paediatrician; former monitor, National Health Mission; former Director, Chhattisgarh Health Resource Centre

(Views are personal)

Jensen Huang says he is willing to return as Nvidia CEO amid US national security scrutiny

Delhi court gives NIA two weeks to provide unrelied documents to Tahawwur Rana

IPL 2027: What lies ahead for MS Dhoni as CSK mentor?

India condemns tanker attack in Strait of Hormuz; one Indian missing, two injured

Thank you, Thala: After 17 years with Super Kings as a player, MS Dhoni bids good bye